|
GUMNUTS |
![]() |
|
Little poems to 8 lines in length, any style, any theme. First prize: A$100
Entry deadline, the end of February annually.
~~ |
| February 2010 Judge's Comments:
Equal First Place
The War Correspondent - by Helen Meikle
Equal First Place
Au Revoir - by teri merlyn
The Exile - by Helen Meikle
Very Highly Commended Laundry Day - by Nola Passmore
Highly Commended
Look at him -
by Vicky Daddo
Fairy Toes - by Mandy Lovell
Red feather sunset -by Fiona McIlroy
sky - by Rosie Schriever
A process - by Vanessa Page
Freeze Frame - by Nola Passmore
Commended
Haiku - by Margaret Young
Emotion - by Jonathan Tromane
Equilibrium - by Anne Hollier
Another - by Keitha Keyes
Fire - by Joanne Mills
Red Centre - by Vanessa Page
|
| February
2009
Judge's Comments: Ruth
Strachan
Just too many good poems, all deserving to get a place! Such has been the quality, we have five pems gaining a Very Highly Commended place. Note that not all three line poems are haiku, but achieve here on other merits. Both the top placed poems are so well focused that the first and last lines are almost linked, but with much eventuating in the few lines between. In The daughter, the portrayal of Winter as a wayward child is highly original .The echoing of "I will" is very effective. The sound effect of the Ws in the first line and the Ms in the last suits the instances. There is a natural rhythm evident. The rhyming is unforced. Every sentence contains action and imagery. And the whole forms an atmosphere. Shards has a sense of immediacy about it, it is happening now, as the reader reads. The echo in I see / I watch / I weep is very effective. The cadences in the last line make a moving closure, along with the N sounds and echo of "know". Shards of grass bring to mind sharp cutting broken glass, and the echo of "green" reinforces the hurt jealousy. Congratulations to all achievers, especially our winners. Ruth Strachan Results Equal First:
sharing the total prize money allotted to first and second places.
The daughter by Rosie Schriever
Shards by Patricia Clark, Victoria
Very Highly Commended
Memorial by David Terelinck
Inside the Firebox by Jenny Pyatt
Highly Commended
Abundance by libby goodsir
Commended
Shark Suit by Carolyn Eldridge-Alfonzetti
Weather Report by Nola Passmore
The Valley by John Egan
Wind by Edel Wignell
Family Reunion by May Zhang
Catnap by Max Merckenschlager
February 2008 Judge's Comments: Ruth Strachan
___________________________________________________________________________________ Results First Place:- Arrow by Patricia Clark, Victoria.
~ Second Place:- Bats by Marianne Musgrove - South Australia
Very Highly Commended: Passing Swans by Max Merkenschlagerl, South Australia
Highly Commended Poems: Winter's Night by Mark Williams, Victoria
Flores by Miles Trench, South Australia
Paparazzi by Patricia Clark, Victoria
Just Like Kids by Max Merckenschlager, S.A
Commended Poems:-
What We Can Learn From Black Sheep by Marianne Musgrove - S. A.
Autumn Shades by Jan Foster, N.S.W.
Release by Mark Williams, Victoria
Unaware by Glenn Bray, Vic
|
|
February 2007 Judge's Comments: Ruth Strachan What a wonderful response to the inaugural Scribbli Gum competition! All entries held interest, and many had a natural rhythm and an echoing of sound, so it was painful to lay some aside. However, some entrants seemed to have tried to fit a longer poem into eight lines, which did not really work well. These pieces could be quite successful in a competition for longer poems. It was good too to see some seemingly simple little poems that were not simplistic, but well crafted. Everything considered, the winner is Blue, in which the atmosphere and the silence are so well presented. It is a poem that calls the reader back to it - congratulations! Second place goes to an unusual and lovely offering, Moonshine, and Very Highly Commendeds go to Rosella and The Last Thing I Saw, two very effective poems. All entries were of a very high standard - thank you for the pleasure of reading them. Ruth Strachan Copyright for all work remains with the author
Results First Place:- Blue by Pat Rosier, New Zealand.
Second Place:- Moon Shine by Em Hofstede - New Zealand
Very Highly Commended: The Last Thing I Saw by Edel Wignell, Victoria, Australia
Rosella by Glennis Henning, NSW, Australia
Highly Commended Poems: Art Deco by Helen Lowe, NZ
Crows by Edel Wignell, Victoria, Australia
Comfort by Dorothy Swoope, NSW Australia
Crows & Haiku by Fred Curtis Victoria, Australia.
quinta essentia by Julie Waugh NSW Australia
Commended poems:- The Naked Heart by Kate Landsberry NSW
Timeless by Kate Landsberry NSW
Home by Jan Foster NSW
The Big OE by Sue Howard New Zealand
Little Icarus by Fred Curtis Victoria Australia |